Clinical Psychology: Research and Practice Innovations

Clinical Psychology: Research and Practice Innovations"

Designing and Evaluating the Effectiveness of Play Therapy method based on Acceptance and Commitment on Shame and Anxiety Symptoms in Abused Children

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
Hajar Bavarsad CheshmehAli 1
narges pourtaleb 2
elnaz mosanejad jedi 3
1 Senior clinical expert for children and adolescents, Rushdieh Institute of Higher Education, Tabriz, Iran
2 Ph.D. in educational psychology, faculty member of the Department of Psychology and Counseling, Farhangian University, Tehran, Iran.
3 Ph.D. in Psychology, Visiting Professor, Department of Psychology, Rushdieh University, Tabriz, Iran
10.22075/jcp.2024.33298.2849
Abstract
Introduction: The purpose of the present study was to design and evaluate the effectiveness of play therapy methods based on acceptance and commitment on shame and anxiety symptoms in abused children aged 8 to 12 years.
Method: The present research was conducted with a mixed method. First, it was designed by relying on the concepts of acceptance and commitment therapy, mindfulness, and using Steven Hayes' mind training guide. 3 children from the city of Isfahan were selected with a purposeful method. Questionnaires of 71 emotional disorders screen and self-aware emotional test-child form were used. Data analysis was done using percentage of recovery, effect size, stable change and visual analysis.
Findings: The treatment was effective on the two variables of shame and anxiety. The face validity of the treatment method was confirmed by experts. The validity of the research was also done by analyzing the data of the single subject design, which showed the improvement of the performance of the subjects.
Conclusion: The treatment led to an improvement in performance, but the effectiveness of the treatment was more significant if the parents were trained. The results of the present research open the way for experimental research in order to increase the power of generalization of the findings.
Keywords
abused child
shame . symptoms of anxiety
play therapy based on acceptance and commitment
Subjects

  1. منابع

    1. Seddighi H, Salmani, I, Javadi M.H & Seddighi S. Child abuse in natural disasters and conflicts: A systematic review. Trauma Violence Abuse. 2021; 22(1): 176-185.
    2. Ansari S. Awareness of Child Sexual Abuse and Preventive and Coping Strategies for Parents and Careers of the Children. J Except Educ 2018; 4 (153):25-32.
    3. Noroozi Chaharghaleh P, Hashemi Azar J & Sarami Forooshani G R. The comparison of neuropsychological function among emotionally abused and normal girl students. J Psychol Stud. 2015; 11(2): 7-24.
    4. Shirmohammadi Z, Sadeghi M and Ghazanfari F. The role of childhood abuse and insecure attachment in explaining adolescent conduct disorder through cognitive processing. J Psychol Stud. 2021; 17(2), 117-138.
    5. Tayyabzadeh Dezfuli S. Child abuse in the family (investigation of child abuse cases in Karaj welfare) [Dissertation]. Tehran.Social and Economic Sciences Al-Zahra (S). 2010. p.10-20.
    6. Qasimabadi N. Investigating the relationship between child abuse, post-traumatic stress disorder and Internet addiction in middle school students of Qom [M.A.Dissertation]. Behshahr. Branch Azad University. 2016. p.20-100.
    7. Adams J. Mrug S. and Knight D. C. Characteristics of child physical and sexual abuse as predictors of psychopathology. Child Abuse Negl 2018; (86): 167-177.
    8. Karimi N, Shahgholian M. Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder, Sluggish Cognitive Tempo and Child Abuse Trauma: A Comparative Study in Men and Women. RRJ 2022; 11 (1):155-162.
    9. Ellenbogen S. Trocme N, Wekerle C and McLeod K. An exploratory study of physical abuse–related shame, guilt, and blame in a sample of youth receiving child protective services: Links to maltreatment, anger, and aggression. J Aggrress Maltreat Trauma. 2015; 24(5): 532-551.
    10. Adams J, Mrug S, and Knight D. C. Characteristics of child physical and sexual abuse as predictors of psychopathology. Child Abuse Negl. 2018; (86): 167-177.
    11. Hashemi S, Dartaj F, Saadipour I and Asadzadeh H. Structural model of shame and guilt feelings based on parenting styles: The mediating role of attachment styles. Int J Appl Psychol. 2018; 11(4 (44)):475-493.
    12. Abbasi N, Hosseini F S, Golestane SM. The role of attribution styles in self-conscious emotions of shame and guilt for elementary school's students, Stud Learn Instruc, 2017; 8(2): 1-18.
    13. Dostani Sh and Qumrani A. Comparing the effectiveness of emotional socialization training and teaching parenting metaphors to mothers on the shame of children with internalized behavioral problems JR-CBS. 2021; 11(2): 27-42.
    14. Haj Akbari A and Abbasi Q. The effectiveness of group therapy based on acceptance and commitment on internalized shame and fear of failure in female students. Rooyesh. 2021; 10(4): 133-142.
    15. Matos M, Pinto‐Gouveia J, and Gilbert P. The effect of shame and shame memories on paranoid ideation and social anxiety. Clin Psychol Psychother. 2013; (20): 334–349.
    16. Diana-Mirela Cândea D.M, and Szentagotai-Tătar A. Shame-proneness, guilt-proneness and anxiety symptoms: A meta-analysis. J Anxity Disord. 2018; (58): 78-106.
    17. Aakvaag H.F, Thoresen S, Wentzel‐Larsen T, Røysamb E, and Dyb G. Shame and guilt in the aftermath of terror: The Uttiya Island study. J Trauma Stress. 2014; 27(5): 618-621.
    18. Aakvaag H. F, Thoresen S, Wentzel-Larsen T, Dyb G, Røysamb E and Olff M. Broken and guilty since it happened: A population study of trauma-related shame and guilt after violence and sexual abuse. J Affect Disord. 2016; (204): 16-23.
    19. Mures P and Meesters C. Small or big in the eyes of the other: On the developmental psychopathology of self-conscious emotions as shame, guilt, and pride. Clin Child Fam Psychol Rev. 2014; 17(1): 19-40.
    20. Haj Mohammadi Z and Haji Alizadeh, K. Effectiveness of fighting cat program on symptoms of generalized anxiety disorder and social phobia in boys and girls with anxiety disorders. JIVMS. 2019; 28(1): 27-35.
    21. Ray D.C, Burgin E, Gutierrez D, Ceballos P, and Lindo N. Child‐centered play therapy and adverse childhood experiences: A randomized controlled trial. J Couns Dev. 2022; 100(2): 134-145.
    22. Lenz A. S. Meta-analysis of the coping cat program for decreasing severity of anxiety symptoms among children and adolescents. J Child Adolesc Couns. 2015; 1(2): 51-65.
    23. AghaBabaei Dastgerdi M. Investigating the effectiveness of compassion-focused therapy on reducing mothers' anger and their children's behavioral problems [Dissertation].Esfehan. Faizul Islam Institute of Higher Education. RCAP. 2019. p.20-132.
    24. Shahabizadeh F. and Khaje Eminian F. The effectiveness of story therapy based on cognitive-behavioral approach on the anxiety of female primary school students. JSRP. 2017; 19(1): 70-80.
    25. Rahmanian M, Mesadi S and Dehestani M. the effect of cognitive rehabilitation training on the improvement of anxiety symptoms in children J Child Ment Health. 2017; 14(5): 48-58.
    26. Miers A, Blöte A, de Rooij M, Bokhorst C.L, & Westenberg P. Trajectories of social anxiety during adolescence and relations with cognition, social competence, and temperament.. J Abnorm Child Psychol. 2013; (41): 97–110.
    27. Crawford A.M & Manassis K. Anxiety, social skills, friendship quality, and peer victimization: An integrated model. J Anxiety Disord. 2011; 25(7): 924-931.
    28. Salehi S, Barjali A and Zadeh Mohammadi A. The effectiveness of drama therapy on the anxiety of working children. J Psychol Achiev. J Educ Psychol. 2022; 29(1): 15-36.
    29. Woods C. Play Therapy in Children with Trauma. Academic Fastival. 2021; 151:2-15.
    30. Godarzi K, Meridian S and Rozbahani M. Determining the effectiveness of play therapy on children's aggression, stress and anxiety. JMBS. 2018; 2(2): 116-125.
    31. Talebi M, Ghasemzadeh S. Arjamandi Rafsanjani K and Vakili S. The effectiveness of child-centered play therapy on the resilience of children with leukemia. JPEN. 2022; (3) 8: 47-55.
    32. Rataghi P and Mareshian F. The effectiveness of doll play therapy on reducing shyness, loneliness and behavioral problems of single-parent children in Ahvaz city. Rooyesh. 2019; 10(12): 179-190.
    33. Shamsipour A, Selgi R, Rozbahani M, Babaei Amiri N and Darabi B. Investigating the effectiveness of play therapy (with a sand play approach) in children with post-traumatic stress disorder. J Except Child. 2017; 18(4): 55-66.
    34. Rezaei A. The effectiveness of play therapy on reducing children's shyness. JR-JNBS. 2017; 3(19): 45-58.
    35. Zare S, Pourshahriari M and Rahimi C. The effect of play therapy on bereavement symptoms in children covered by the Imam Khomeini Relief Committee. Couns Res Dev. 2016; 16(63): 81-98.‌
    36. Khoshiari Murad S and Nik Amal M. The effectiveness of game therapy on reducing hidden and overt anxiety of abused girls aged 4-12 living in quasi-family centers. Rooyesh. 2019; 9(4): 65-74.
    37. Mortazavi, A, Nikrahan Gh and Sadoughi M. Comparing the effectiveness of play therapy methods based on acceptance and commitment and combining it with mothers' education on anxiety, self-esteem and self-efficacy of elementary school children, J Clin Psychol. 2017; (3)10: 77-89.
    38. Hossein Ava, Z. Mahmoud Alilou, M. Nemati, F. The effect of anger management training based on acceptance and commitment on adolescent anger rumination with a single case design [Dissertation]. Tabriz. Faculty of Education Sciences and Psychology.2023; p.10_50.
    39. Paktinatan, E. Chinaveh,M. Fereydoni, S. The Effectiveness of Compassion-based Acceptance and Commitment Group Therapy on Adjustment and Happiness in Patients with Major Depression Disorder. IEEPJ. 2022; 4(1), 25-35.
    40. Azizi, M. Farhangi, A. Hosseinpour, R Comparison of the Effectiveness of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy and Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction Therapy on Academic Belief, Emotional Regulation, and Academic Adjustment, J Psychol Achiev. 2023; 30(1), 261-284.
    41. Aghili, M. Mahghani Gheshlagh, Z. Asghari,A. The effectiveness of acceptance and commitment based therapy on aggression, emotion regulation and life expectancy of socially disadvantaged girls, JMPR. 2023; 18(70), 187-194.
    42. Mahmoudfakhe, H. Shiri,H. Rezaei, N. Comparison of the effect of acceptance and commitment therapy and self-compassion therapy on cognitive flexibility in anxious female students of the second year of high school, PPLS. (2024); 9(3), 63-81.
    43. Asadi, Mohammadi, M. Naziri, GH. Davoodi, A. Comparing of Clinical Efficacy of ACT Matrix with ACT Focused on Compassion and Hofmann's CBT on Social Anxiety Disorder, J Appl Psychol. 2023; 17(2), 33-61.
    44. Vosough S and Mohajerani M. The Effectiveness of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy in Reducing the Symptoms of Anxiety Disorders in Children from at Risk Families. QJFR. 2022; 18 (4):131-144.
    45. Luoma J B & Platt M G. Shame, self-criticism, self-stigma, and compassion in acceptance and commitment therapy. Curr Opin Psychol. 2015; 2: 97-101.
    46. Gul M and Aqeel M. Acceptance and commitment therapy for treatment of stigma and shame in substance use disorders: a diuble-blind, parallel-group, randomized controlled trial.. J Subst Use. 2021; 26(4): 413-419.
    47. Parazdeh Y, Viyani F, Zamani S and Zamani N. The Effectiveness of Acceptance and Commitment-Based Education on Anxiety, Depression and Rumination in and 16-Year-Old Adolescents with Multiple Sclerosis (Case Study). Pajouhan Sci J. 2022; 20 (2):120-126.
    48. Mirjalili R, Rasulzadeh Tabatabai K and Ghanbzodgi M. Investigating the confirmatory factor structure and psychoanalytical characteristics of the adult version of the screening questionnaire for emotional disorders related to child anxiety. Clin Psychol Personal. Period 16. 2016; 1(30): 223-237.
    49. Beit Saeed M. Developing and testing a model of the causal relationship between different aspects of self-discord with self-criticism, rumination and fear of intimacy, with the mediation of emotions of shame and guilt in students of Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz [Dissertation]. Ahvaz. Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz. 2015; p.10-117.
    50. Abbasi N, Hosseini F and Golestane M. The role of attribution styles in self-conscious emotions of shame and guilt for elementary school's students, Stud Learn Inst. 2017; 8(2): 1-18.
    51. Ghazizadeh S, Mashhadhi A, Tabibi Z and Soltanifar A. The effectiveness of trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy on the symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder in children with sexual abuse experience. J Clin Psychol. 2019; (4) 12: 77-90.
    52. Khorianian M. Bakshipour Rudsari A, Mahmoudalilo M and Hashemi T. Effectiveness of transference psychotherapy on reflective action and symptom reduction in patients with borderline personality disorder. J Clin Psychol.2017; 4(40): 45-57.
    53. Khojasteh Mehr R, Koochaki R and Rajabi GH. Mediating role of relationship attributions and destructive conflict resolution strategies on the relationship between attachment styles and marital quality. Contemp psychol. 2013; 7(2): 3-10.
    54. Aghaei A, Kara Ahmadi M and Asgari A. Comparing the effectiveness of child-centered play therapy and parental play therapy on reducing children's internalizing disorders, J Res Behave Sci. 2014; (2) 321: 13-309.
    55. Qomian S and Shoairi M R. The effectiveness of treatment based on acceptance and commitment of children with chronic pain on the internalized symptoms of 7-12-year-old children with chronic pain. Clin Psychol Stud (JCPS). 2016; 8(29): 1-19.
    56. Shujaei Z, Gol Paror M, Bardbar M and Aghaei A. The effect of cognitive behavioral play therapy and cognitive behavioral story therapy on the perception of pain and hope in children with cancer, J Nurs Educ (JPEN). 2018; (1) 6: 45-39.
    57. Shamabadi R, Nosratabadi M, Asgharinekah S M, and Banihashem A. Effect of Group Play Therapy based on Choice Theory on Anxiety, Depression, and Pain Symptoms in Children and Adolescents with Cancer. J Mazandaran Univ Med Sci 2021; 31 (197):154-161.
    58. Bagheri P, Yousefi afrashte M. Comparison of the effectiveness of painting therapy and group play therapy on anxiety and self-esteem of students with Attention Deficit / Hyperactivity Disorder (AD/HD). J Except Educ. 2021; 2 (162):114-114.
    59. Aghajani S, Abedi S, Hoseyni A. Comparison of the effectiveness of play therapy and laughter therapy in Catarria (laughter yoga) on generalized anxiety in children aged 6-12 years. Shenakht. J Psychol Psychiatr. 2021; 8 (1):74-87.
    60. Mohammadi GH, Pirani Z, Zangeneh Motlag F. Comparison of the effectiveness of philosophy program for children and group play therapy with cognitive-behavioral method on psychological flexibility in children with separation anxiety disorder. Think Child. 2023; 13(2): 215-239.
    61. Swain J, Hancock K, Dixon A & Bowman J. Acceptance and Commitment Therapy for children: A systematic review of intervention studies. J Contextual Behav Sci. 2015; 4(2): 73-85.
    62. Gardner M J, Thomas H J & Erskine H E. The association between five forms of child maltreatment and depressive and anxiety disorders: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Child Abuse Negl. 2919; 96 (10): 40-82.
    63. Fang S & Ding D. A meta-analysis of the efficacy of acceptance and commitment therapy for children. J Contextual Behav Sci. 2020; 15: 225-234.
    64. Ray D C, Burgin E, Gutierrez D, Ceballos P & Lindo N. Child‐centered play therapy and adverse childhood experiences: A randomized controlled trial. J Couns Dev (JCD). 2022; 100(2): 134-145.
    65. Abusaeidi Moghadam N, Sanagouye Moharer Gh R & Shirazi M. Effectiveness of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) on feelings of loneliness, shame, and guilt in female applicants for divorce, J Appli Psychol. 2020; 14(1): 35-54.
    66. Hadiyan Najafabadi M and Kazemi M. Effectiveness of Acceptance & Commitment Therapy (ACT) on Generalized Anxiety Disorder in Children with Type 1 Diabetes, Ilam Uni Med Sci. 2018; 25(6): 185-198.

    67. Pourtaleb N, Badri R, Nemati S, Hashemi T. Developing and Validation the Acceptance and Commitment Education Program and Evaluation its efficiency on Academic Resilience, Academic Stress and Academic Burnout for Students with Specific Learning Disability. JOEC. 2023; 23 (2):7-2

  • Receive Date 15 February 2024
  • Revise Date 10 June 2024
  • Accept Date 19 June 2024
  • First Publish Date 19 June 2024
  • Publish Date 20 March 2024